Maybe closer to 4.5 stars rating. We stayed at this property for 4 nights. We spent most of our time at Gettysburg, which was only a 20 min. drive or so away. We also hiked at Cunningham Falls State Park in Maryland which was also less than a half hour away. And we made a surprise stop at the Utz factory store 20 mins. away. So the location was good for our activities. The property is on a big creek/small river and we saw some ducks, but didn't catch any fish. It was too cold to really enjoy any of the outdoor amenities, Spring is a tricky time of year. The kitchen had everything we needed and we were surprised there were two full bathrooms as the house isn't that large, so that was nice. We were comfortable during our stay. Brenda was very available to answer a couple of questions we had.