Shelter Island pet-friendly rentals

Stay in one of our 993 pet-friendly vacation rentals in Shelter Island and you’ll have a perfect base for your next trip with your four-legged friend. Menantic Creek, Coecles Harbor and The Heights are some of the city’s most sought-after neighborhoods.

Exactly where you stay, when you plan to travel and the length of your trip will influence the price of a pet-friendly vacation rental in Shelter Island. Key in your travel details on Vrbo to easily compare properties and then choose the best one for you and your dog.

It all comes down to what you want to do with your pup. Do you enjoy an action-packed type of adventure? Or do you prefer to kick back and relax in a homey pet-friendly vacation rental? The weather, temperatures and the high and low seasons are just a few extra factors to consider when arranging a getaway with your furry best friend.

It’s easy to book a pet-friendly vacation rental in Shelter Island with amazing views with Vrbo’s handy filter tool. Select “Location” to browse properties in scenic areas or with specific vistas that both you and your furry friend will enjoy. You can also find vacation homes that previous Vrbo guests think highly of by clicking on “Guest rating.”

Let your furry companion be part of the vacation fun at one of our pet-friendly vacation rentals by the beach in Shelter Island. Browse our options around top spots like 67 Steps Beach and Orient Beach State Park and spend your days taking long strolls along the seashore or playing fetch.

To find pet-friendly vacation rentals in Shelter Island with an outdoor space, select “Garden or backyard” under the features and amenities filter. Some of our properties come with fenced gardens, while others are close to parks, trails or other pet-friendly areas.

Embrace nature’s wonders with your furry friend right by your side at one of our pet-friendly cabins or lodges in Shelter Island. Use our “Pet-friendly” filter to refine your search for stays that offer an unforgettable experience for the entire family — four-legged members included.

Shelter Island has many top-rated attractions that’ll appeal to the whole family, such as East Hampton Main Beach and Orient Point County Park. Make time for a stop at 67 Steps Beach too. After locking in your pet-friendly vacation rental, do some digging into the kind of places that you can explore with your dog. Your stay will likely have some terrific ideas, so be sure to ask.

With our comprehensive filter tool, booking a getaway with your pooch has never been simpler. Fine-tune your search for a homey pet-friendly vacation rental by things like amenities, budget and location. Our Book with Confidence guarantee also means that you’ll get payment protection and 24/7 customer support during your trip. For more peace of mind, opt for one of our rentals that offer flexible cancellation policies. On top of all that, our free rewards program, One Key™, lets you earn OneKeyCash™* on eligible bookings on Vrbo, Expedia and Hotels.com. *OneKeyCash disclaimer - OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Hotels.com, Expedia and Vrbo.